Why Not Annihilate All Forms? 为何不断灭一切相?


[Of] people mindful [of] Buddha, [when] approaching [the] end [of life, who] receive [Amitābha] Buddha’s receiving [and] guiding, [this] indeed [is of] sentient beings [and the] Buddha attaining connection [and] response [for] mutual interaction.

[Note 1: This is as promised by the Buddha in the sūtras. This is also sometimes witnessed by those offering support-chanting for the dying.]


Although not departing [from the] mind [of] perception, [you] also must not say [this] is only [as] perception’s mind that appears, [that it is] absolutely without [the] Buddha [and his] noble [assembly’s] matter of receiving [and] guiding.

[Note 2: Even if perception is yet to be fully purified, with the Three Provisions of Faith, Aspiration and Practice adequate, the Buddha will definitely come to receive and guide to his Pure Land.]


[The] mind creates hell, [when] approaching [the] end [of life], thus [does] hell’s forms appear.

[Note 3: When the mind gives rise to hell-aligned or hellish thoughts karmically, signs of hell will appear, thus leading to a hellish rebirth…]


[The] mind creates [the] Buddha Land, [when] approaching [the] end [of life], thus [does the] Buddha Land’s forms appear.

[Note 4: … unless such thoughts (in Note 2) are transformed in time, best by mindfulness of Buddha with the Three Provisions.]


Saying [that] forms accord [with the] mind appearing [is] thus alright, [while] saying [they are] mind-only without [their] realms [is] thus not alright.

[Note 5: There are both states of mind and their karmically corresponding realms – at individual and collective levels. For example, an individual can create negative karma to experience a Solitary/ Lonely/ Isolated Hell (孤独地狱) all by oneself, or create adequate collective pure karma (净业) with others, including the Buddha, to experience his Pure Land (净土).]


[Of that] mind-only without [any] realms, [this] needs speak of [the] great awakened World-Honoured [One’s] complete realisation [of] mind-only, [which is] thus without fault.

[Note 6: Only the Buddhas have fully purified minds free from all habitual and karmic misperceptions, thus able to be free from all realms that arise  accordingly. Ordinary beings’ perception of the Buddhas, his noble assembly and his Pure Land, as enabled by them cannot be due to misperception, even if not with fully purified perception yet.]


Your distinguished self, if saying [as you had said], thus falls [into] annihilation’s [wrong] view, [which] is [an] evil teaching [that] destroys [the] Thus Come [One’s] Dharma Door [for] cultivation [and] realisation. [How] can all not [be] cautious [of this]?

[Note 7: There should not be assumption that all forms perceived by those yet to be fully purified are totally false or useless, especially since some of these forms are necessary, as skilfully manifested by the pure to guide and receive towards full purification, especially through Pure Land, which only has pure forms, as created and sustained by the Buddha’s pure mind.]

Pure Land Tradition’s 13th Patriarch Great Master Yìnguāng
Reply Letter To Layperson Xiǎnwéi

Namo Amituofo : Translation and notes by Shen Shi’an

Please be mindful of your speech, Amituofo!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.